Debit vs Credit: What’s the Best Choice for Kids?

Modak
November 19, 2024

When it comes to managing money, the decision between a debit card and a credit card is one that most adults face. But when it comes to kids and teens, the stakes are a little different. With financial education becoming more important at a younger age, it's critical to understand the pros and cons of both options. So, which is better for kids—debit or credit?

In this guide, we’ll cover key information to help you make the best decision for your child. By the end, you'll gain insights into why a debit card can often be a safer and smarter option for children, especially when using an app like Modak1, which also provides a range of helpful financial tools. Let’s dive in and explore the differences between these two financial options!

What Is a Debit Card?

A debit card is a card that allows the user to spend money directly from their bank account. Every time you use a debit card, the money is withdrawn immediately from the funds available in your account. For kids and teens, this can be a great way to control spending because they can only use the money they already have.

Girl making a purchase online with her debit card

Benefits of Debit Cards for Kids

  • Easy to understand: Kids know that they can only spend what they have in their account.
  • No debt risk: There's no borrowing involved, so kids don’t have to worry about interest or late fees.
  • Budgeting tool: By using a debit card, kids can learn how to manage their own money.

One standout feature of debit cards, especially in a product like Modak, is the ability for parents to monitor and guide their child's financial habits, setting limits and tracking transactions to promote good money management.

What Is a Credit Card?

On the other hand, a credit card allows the user to borrow money from the credit card issuer, up to a set credit limit. The borrowed money must be paid back, often with interest. Credit cards come with more responsibility and risk, particularly for kids and teens.

Risk of Credit Cards vs Debit Cards

  • Debt risk: Credit cards allow you to spend more money than you have, which can easily lead to debt.
  • Interest and fees: If the balance isn’t paid in full, kids may face interest charges or late fees.
  • Temptation to overspend: Having access to credit may encourage irresponsible spending habits.

For kids, a debit card is usually a safer, simpler option because it limits spending to what’s available and avoids the complexities and risks of debt.

Which Is Better for Kids: Debit or Credit?

Now that we understand the basics, the question remains: which is better for kids—debit or credit?

For most children and teens, the clear winner is the debit card. Here’s why:

  1. Financial Responsibility: A debit card helps kids learn how to manage money they actually have, which builds budgeting and saving skills.
  2. No Risk of Debt: Since debit cards only use available funds, kids won’t accidentally go into debt.
  3. Parental Oversight: With apps like Modak, parents can easily monitor transactions, set spending limits, and help their children stay financially responsible.
  4. Safer for Everyday Use: If your child loses their card, there's no worry about someone racking up charges—they can only spend what’s in the account.

Can Minors Get Debit Cards?

Yes, minors can get debit cards, but they often need a parent or guardian to help open the account. With Modak, for instance, parents are required to go through a KYC (Know Your Customer) process to ensure security. Once the account is set up, kids can start using their own debit card, both virtual and physical, to make purchases.

Debit Cards for Teens: A Great Learning Tool

Debit cards provide a low-risk way for teens to learn about money management. Many parents prefer debit cards over credit because they offer a more controlled environment for financial learning. By limiting spending to what's available in the account, kids can make real-time decisions about their purchases and learn important financial lessons along the way.

Leather wallet with debit and credit cards inside

Prepaid Debit Cards with No Fees

For parents and kids concerned about hidden fees, Modak offers a debit card with no monthly fees, no subscription costs, and no minimum deposit requirements4. This makes it an excellent option for families who want to give their kids financial independence without the stress of managing fees.

Debit vs Credit: Key Differences

Let’s break down some of the key differences between debit and credit cards:

Debit Card

  • Funds come from your account: No borrowing or credit involved.
  • No interest: You’re not charged for carrying a balance.
  • Low risk: Kids can only spend the money they have, limiting the risk of financial mismanagement.

Credit Card

  • Borrowing money: You’re using the credit card issuer’s funds, and you’ll need to pay them back.
  • Interest charges: If the balance isn’t paid in full, you’ll face interest charges, often at high rates.
  • Risk of debt: Credit cards can encourage overspending, leading to debt.

FAQs: Debit vs Credit for Kids

Is it better to have a credit card or debit card?

For kids, a debit card is generally better. It helps them learn financial responsibility without the risk of going into debt, and with apps like Modak, parents can oversee their child’s spending and help guide their decisions.

What is the difference between a credit card and a debit card?

A credit card lets you borrow money that must be repaid with interest, while a debit card draws directly from the user’s bank account, allowing them to spend only what they have.

Is an ATM card a credit card?

No, an ATM card allows you to withdraw cash directly from your bank account without borrowing money. While it’s worth noting that some credit cards also offer a cash withdrawal option at ATMs, this involves borrowing funds with interest and often incurs additional fees, making it a less advisable choice for most users.

What are the disadvantages of a debit card?

The main disadvantage of a debit card is that it doesn’t help build a credit history like a credit card can. However, for kids and teens, this is often less of a concern. Another potential drawback is that funds are limited to what’s in the account, so it can be inconvenient if an emergency expense arises.

Why Modak’s Debit Card is a Great Choice for Kids

Girl holding Modak Makers debit card

Modak’s debit card offers the perfect combination of security, convenience, and financial learning for kids and teens. Here’s why Modak is a fantastic option:

  • No Fees: Modak doesn’t charge monthly fees or subscription costs4, so your child can use their debit card without worrying about hidden charges.
  • Earn While Learning: Through the app, kids can earn MBX—Modak’s in-app reward point system—by completing healthy challenges like walking or achieving savings goals. They can even convert these points into USD to use on their debit card. For example: By walking 5,000 steps every day, children can earn up to 70 MBX per week, which translates to an extra $8 per week just by staying active(2)(3).
  • Parental Control: Modak allows parents to set chores, monitor transactions, and guide their child’s financial decisions in real-time.
  • Financial Literacy: With Modak’s tools, kids can learn the basics of budgeting, saving, and responsible spending in a fun, interactive way.

Ready to Take the First Step?

If you're looking to give your child a head start on financial literacy and responsibility, Modak’s debit card is the perfect tool. With no monthly fees, easy parental controls, and opportunities for kids to earn and learn, it’s a great option to help them manage money while building good habits for the future.

Get started with Modak today and help your child become financially savvy while keeping their money safe!

  1. Modak is a financial technology company and not a FDIC-insured bank.Checking account and the Modak Visa® debit card issued by Lewis & Clark Bank, Member FDIC. Funds deposited into checking account may be eligible for up to $250,000 of FDIC insurance. The FDIC’s deposit insurance coverage only protects against the failure of an FDIC-insured depository institution.
  2. 100 MBX = $1(as of June 2024). This is an approximation and not a guaranteed result. For more information on MBX click here.
  3. Walking 5,000 steps a day gives users 10MBX (as of June 2024). This is subject to change at Modak’s discretion
  4. Fees for expedited or premium services may apply. Find out more in our Cardholder agreement.

Follow us on social media:

Related articles

Browse all articles